Home Insurance
Homeowners, wind & hurricane, renters and condo coverage — built for Florida risks, including older roofs and storm season.
Protection with Principle.
Our new website is almost ready. Probity Insurance LLC is an independent, veteran owned and operated agency — we shop multiple carriers to find the right coverage for Florida families and businesses, and we explain it in plain English.
- AUTO
- HOME
- LIFE
- BUSINESS
We’re putting the finishing touches on the site. Our full website launches soon — check back, we look forward to serving you.
Coverage for what matters to you
When we launch, you’ll be able to explore all of our coverage right here. Here’s a first look at what we’ll offer.
Auto Insurance
Personal auto and trucks, uninsured motorist coverage, and SR-22 filings — balanced for price and real protection on Florida roads.
Life Insurance
Term life, whole life & final expense, and mortgage protection — sized honestly to take care of the people you love.
Business Insurance
General liability, commercial auto, workers’ compensation, and commercial property for shops, contractors, and service businesses.
Why an independent agency?
A captive agent can only sell one company’s policies. As an independent agency, we work for you — not for one carrier.
We shop for you
We compare multiple carriers for you, so you’re never limited to one company’s price or policy.
Plain-English advice
Straight answers, no pressure, and no fine-print games. You’ll understand your coverage before you sign anything.
Local & veteran owned
Our name is on the door and our reputation is local — based in Winter Haven, serving clients across Florida.
Meet your team
Probity is a family-run, veteran owned and operated agency.
Mario Insua
OWNER / COO
A Marine Corps veteran, Mario brings the discipline, integrity, and sense of duty forged in his service to everything he does. After his service, he spent over 20 years in the security industry, becoming Vice President of Operations — leading teams, running complex operations, and earning a reputation for straight talk and follow-through.
Mario founded Probity on a simple, personal standard: know people by name, listen first, and look out for them the way you’d look out for family and neighbors — because here, that’s exactly what they are. When you work with Mario, you’re not a policy number. You’re someone he knows, someone he’ll sit down with, talk through things straight, and be there for when you need him. That’s protection, with principle — personal, honest, and rooted in trust.
Shauna Insua
PRESIDENT / AGENT
Backed by 17 years as a licensed insurance agent, Shauna is passionate about helping individuals, families, and businesses safeguard what matters most. She specializes in both personal and commercial lines, turning confusing policy language into straightforward, customized coverage plans.
Clients rely on her for honest guidance, quick follow-through, and genuine advocacy when it matters most. Away from her desk, you can find her spending quality time with her family, staying active, and making time for daily mindfulness.
Based in Winter Haven, Polk County — serving all of Florida.
Winter Haven · Bartow · Lakeland · Auburndale · Lake Wales · Haines City · and statewide.